IYMC Logo

Probability Without Replacement Explained With Marbles

By Julia Berens · · 4 min read

A hazy, bright cloud formation glows against a deep blue sky, with soft white highlights and wisps of cyan.

Here is probability without replacement explained with five marbles: three red and two blue. Mix them in a bag, draw one without looking, and set it aside. Now draw again. If the first marble was red, the chance of getting red on the second draw is 1/2. If the first marble was blue, that chance is 3/4. The second draw is random in both cases, but it starts from a different bag.

Probability without replacement explained one draw at a time

Assume every marble still in the bag is equally likely to be drawn. On the first draw, each of the five marbles has the same chance of coming out. Three are red, so the probability of red is 3/5. The other two are blue, so the probability of blue is 2/5.

After the first draw, four marbles remain. That gives you the denominator for either second-draw probability. To find the numerator, you need to know which color left the bag.

  • Red came out first: Two red and two blue marbles remain. The probability of red next is 2/4 = 1/2.
  • Blue came out first: Three red and one blue marble remain. The probability of red next is 3/4.

These are conditional probabilities: each is calculated given a particular first result. The word given tells you which bag to count. For example, “red on the second draw given blue on the first” does not ask how likely the first blue was. It asks what fraction of the remaining marbles are red once you know a blue one is gone.

Read the two draws on a tree diagram

Read this tree from left to right. The first branches show what can happen on the first draw. The branches that follow show what can happen on the second draw from that particular bag. In the outcome labels, RB means red first and blue second.

Start
|-- Red (3/5)
|   |-- Red  (2/4)   RR
|   `-- Blue (2/4)   RB
`-- Blue (2/5)
    |-- Red  (3/4)   BR
    `-- Blue (1/4)   BB

The probabilities leaving any one point add to 1. After blue comes out first, for instance, the next draw must be red or blue, and 3/4 + 1/4 = 1. But 2/4 and 3/4 do not have to add to 1. They describe the same color on the second draw under two different conditions.

Multiply along a path to find the probability of that exact sequence. For RR, the first draw has to be red, which happens with probability 3/5. Of the times it is red, half will have a red second draw. So the probability of two reds is (3/5)(2/4) = 3/10.

If you want one marble of each color, either order counts. Multiply along each matching path, then add the results. The red-then-blue path gives (3/5)(2/4) = 3/10. The blue-then-red path gives (2/5)(3/4) = 3/10. The total is 3/5. Adding works because a single pair of draws cannot be both RB and BR.

Put the first marble back and compare

Now return the first marble to the bag and mix again before drawing the second. No matter which color came out first, the bag is back to three red and two blue. On the tree, both sets of second branches would read 3/5 for red and 2/5 for blue. The first result no longer changes the probabilities for the second. In this setup, the draws are independent.

EventWithout replacementWith replacement
Red second, given red first2/43/5
Red second, given blue first3/43/5
Two reds3/10(3/5)(3/5) = 9/25
One of each color3/52 × (3/5)(2/5) = 12/25

Notice that leaving a marble out makes two reds less likely but makes a mixed pair more likely in this bag. The branch counts show why: after drawing a red, the fraction of blue marbles rises from 2/5 to 2/4; after drawing a blue, the fraction of red marbles rises from 3/5 to 3/4. In either case, the color you did not draw takes up a larger share of what remains.

The second draw before you know the first result

Suppose someone draws the first marble and sets it aside without telling you its color. You want the probability that the next marble is red. You cannot use just 1/2 or just 3/4, because you do not know which branch you are on. Use the whole tree and add the paths that end in red: RR and BR.

P(red second) = (3/5)(2/4) + (2/5)(3/4) = 3/10 + 3/10 = 3/5.

That is the same probability as red on the first draw. There is a quick way to see why. Imagine drawing all five marbles without replacement and lining them up in the order you draw them. Each individual marble is equally likely to occupy the second position. Three of the five are red, so the chance of red in that position is 3/5. Equal probabilities at the two positions do not make the draws independent: knowing the first color still changes what you should expect at the second position.

Try a shortcut for at least one red

Keep the same bag and draw twice without replacement. The event “at least one red” includes RR, RB, and BR. Instead of adding three paths, find the one path that does not count. That is BB, with probability (2/5)(1/4) = 1/10. Subtract from 1 to get 9/10.

Now put the first marble back. Only the second factor on the BB path changes: it is 2/5 instead of 1/4. The answer is now 1 − (2/5)(2/5) = 21/25. Keeping the same path makes it easy to see exactly where replacement changes the calculation.

For another practice problem, change the starting bag to four red marbles and one blue marble. Draw the tree before doing any arithmetic and mark the branch that becomes impossible without replacement. Then compare your work with the kinds of problems you find in the IYMC training and practice problems or keep reading in Mathematics Explained.

Frequently asked questions

Do I always subtract one from the numerator?

No. Subtract one from the total number of marbles, but reduce the count for a color only if the first marble was that color.

When do I multiply or add on a probability tree?

Multiply the branch probabilities along one path. Add the probabilities of separate paths that all satisfy the event you want.

Can the second draw have the same red probability as the first?

Yes. Before you know the first result, both draws have a 3/5 chance of red in this example. Once you know the first result, the second-draw probability changes to 1/2 or 3/4.